The Invisible Engine Paradox (Why the same scientist who laughs at angels still trusts a neural net no one can fully explain)

on

The Punch-Line Up Front

“Religious people are mocked for believing in an unseen God, yet the same lab coats will bet a grant renewal on the outputs of a 175-billion-parameter black box they cannot inspect, replicate, or debug.”


2. A Tale of Two Invisibles

Table


Copy

Belief System

Core Object of Faith

Evidence Demanded

Evidence Actually Available

Traditional Theism

God, soul, afterlife

Repeatable miracles, scripture

Subjective experience, historical texts

Modern AI Scientism

“The model is correct”

Peer review, benchmarks

Weights we can’t read, training sets we can’t publish, hallucinations we can’t predict

3. The Lab Coat Sermon

  • “Trust the data” — but the data is petabytes of copyrighted text no human can audit.
  • “Trust the metrics” — but the metrics (BLEU, ROUGE, MMLU) are statistical rituals that collapse when adversarial prompts arrive.
  • “Trust the peer review” — yet the reviewers themselves admit “we don’t know why it works.”


4. Double Standards in Action

Table


Copy

When a Theist Says…

The AI Scientist Replies…

Irony Check

“I feel the presence of God”

“Anecdote ≠ evidence”

“I feel the model is aligned”

“Scripture is inspired”

“Circular reasoning”

“Training loss converged; therefore it’s correct”

“Miracles can’t be reproduced”

“Extraordinary claims need data”

“Emergence can’t be reproduced; still publish”

5. The Mystery Gap Is Bigger for AI

  • God is at least logically simple (omnipotent, omniscient).
  • A transformer’s attention heads interact in non-linear, high-dimensional ways that make weather systems look like Lego bricks.
  • Result: theologist can summarize God in three words; AI researcher needs three PhDs and still says “it’s complicated.”


6. Cargo Cults 2.0

We’ve replaced incense and chanting with hyperparameter tuning and temperature sampling.

Both are rituals performed in front of an opaque oracle whose inner logic remains unseen.


7. A Humble Proposal

Before we ridicule the invisible God of our neighbor, let’s acknowledge the invisible gradients inside our own GPUs.

Either both deserve skepticism, or both deserve humility—but the same standard must apply.


🔚 Closing Benediction

May your priors be updated, your humility gradient-descended, and your epistemic arrogance over-fitted into oblivion.